The Domesday Survey does not mention a church in Upper Gravenhurst, but records that Hugh de Beauchamp held land in Gravenhurst. VCH records that the manor of Upper Gravenhurst (also known as Great Gravenhurst or Tewelsbury) was held by Ramsey Abbey and that this remained the case until the Dissolution (VCH, 333).
Upper Gravenhurst did not have a parish, so a chantry was provided. The existence of the chantry is mentioned in 1189 and 1195 in documents recording that Hugh, Bishop of Lincoln granted the tithes belonging to the chapel of Gravenhurst to Ramsey Abbey (VCH, 336).