Caynham was held by Earl Morcar in 1066, and by Ralph de Mortimer from Earl Roger of Shrewsbury. It was assessed at 8 hides, 4 of which were in demesne. Of the remaining 4 hides, 3 were held from Ralph by Robert de Vessey and one by Walter. There is no mention of a church in the Domesday Survey, but the manor had a mill and enough woodland for fattening 200 pigs. The first documented incumbent of Caynham is Achelard of Caynham, who died during the reign of Henry II. The next recorded incumbent, according to a list in the church, is Sir John de Kayham in 1279.