No church was mentioned in the Domesday Book (1086). Shipley was given to the Priory of Sele by William de Braose, then passed on to the Knights Templar between 1125 and 1130. The present building was probably built by the Knights Templars as a preceptory (late 1130s?).
The N aisle, and a new N porch, were added in 1829-31. The N aisle was rebuilt in 1893 by J. L. Pearson, who also added the vestry.