Alton was a royal manor before the Conquest, and was recorded in Domesday Book as Aultone. It was granted to New Minster (Hyde Abbey), Winchester, in 1072, but no church was mentioned in 1086. A new nave and chancel were added in the early 15thc.
The church was restored in 1867-68 to designs by Ewan Christian, carried out by the local firm Dyer & Sons. At the same time, a new font was carved by the vicar. The old font was reportedly discarded, but rediscovered in 1934 at Will Hall Farm on the outskirts of Alton (or, by some accounts, in Cirencester) and bought back to the church (information inside church). Additions of 1867-68 included an external stair turret serving the belfry and an organ chamber over a boiler room for a hot water heating system. The clearance of galleries and raising of the belfry revealed the Norman arches with their carved capitals which had been ‘almost hidden from observation’ (Hants Chronicle, 18 April 1868, 5).