The Domesday Survey records that in 1066 and 1086 'Fiseledene' was held by Harding, son of Alnoth; it valued £9. In the late 12thc Henry Hussey held the manor. The overlordship may have descended in the Hussey family until 1319 with Knighton manor but is not expressly said to have done so.
In 1115 Henry I granted Figheldean church to Old Sarum and Bishop Roger, but he gave up his right to the dean and chapter. The church was taken from the cathedral in the 1140s but in 1157 it was restored by Henry II. The rectory was appropriated to the treasurer of the cathedral, apparently before 1180–5 when the church was granted for payments of £10 a year to him, and by 1291 a vicarage had been ordained. The treasurer fulfilled all the functions of the ordinary in the parish from c.1190 until his peculiar jurisdiction was abolished in 1841; the church was also exempt from archidiaconal jurisdiction from c.1190.