In 1086, as in 1066, the Archbishop of York held one church and six chapels in Mottisfont (Mortesfunde). The chapels were Broughton, Pittleworth, East Tytherley, West Tytherley, (East) Dean and Lockerley. It has been suggested that Mottisfont was an Anglo-Saxon Minster, supporting these associated parishes. It continued to be held by the archbishops of York until 1547.
The church was restored in 1874 and 1887-88. In 1874 it was reported: ‘The north side of the space under the belfry is set apart for the baptistery, the old font of Purbeck marble, which has not been used for many years, but which has lately been repolished, being placed near the west wall’ (Wilts County Mirror, 1 September 1874, 8).