West Wittering is mentioned in the Domesday Book, but no church. The church was restored by William White in 1875. In the course of the work a Purbeck marble coffin lid carved with a cross and a staff, probably of 13thc. date, was discovered (Horsham Express 20 June 1875, 2). Another find was a stone carved with a cross within a circle, identified as an Anglo-Saxon gable cross (Corpus of Anglo-Saxon Sculpture).