The church was originally the hospitium at the gate of the Priory of St. Pancras, which was converted into a parish church in the 13thc when, possibly, the new Hospital of St. James was built close by.
The older literature makes Gundrada (d.1085) a daughter of William the Conqueror, but this is no longer accepted by modern historians who believe she was of Flemish origin. The arrangement of inscriptions on her tomb slab, however, bears strong similarities to that of Matilda, William's queen, in the Abbaye aux Dames at Caen. There is no record of an earlier memorial before the pair were reburied in the new chapter house, probably in the 1160s. Their tombs wer removed at the Dissolution, and in 1775 Dr Clarke, Rector of Buxted, discovered Gundrada's tomb which had been re-used on the table tomb of Edward Shirley in Isfield church. The trimming of the slab was apparently to makem it fit the Shirley tomb. William Burrell paid for its removal to St John's, Southover, and it was placed in the rectory pew until the present chapel was built for it in 1845-47.