The Domesday Survey records that Fincham was a large settlement, and 6 tenants-in-chief are listed. They were William of Warenne, Hermer of Ferrers, Reginald son of Ivo, Ralph Baynard, and the abbeys of Bury St Edmunds and Ely. Both St Martin's and St Michaels are described at length in Blomefield and Parkin (1807), 354-64, from which it is clear that St Michael's, the original home of the font, was standng and roofed with lead when Parkin saw it. Although the volume was not published until 1807, Blomefield had died in 1752 and Parkin in 1765.