Gwynne and Hadcock suggest that a church on this site may have been built by St Patrick. There is a well nearby, where the saint is supposed to have performed baptism. The Primates of Armagh, who styled themselves successors of St Patrick, claimed title to sites thought to have been founded by the saint. Turlough was among these, part of 'Patrick's lands in Connaught'.
There was a monastery at Turlough of some importance. This was held by Armagh from early times until the 13thc., although Archbishop Felix O'Ruadhan of Tuam maintained in 1210 that the church was built and maintained by his predecessors.
The Annals of Loch Ce record that the church was pillaged by Mac William in 1236.