The Domesday Survey does not distinguish between the settlements of Deeping St James, West Deeping and Market Deeping. A holding of 3 carucates and 4 bovates belonged to Almaer and Arnbiorn and Fredegaest in 1066, and to Geoffrey de Cambrai in 1086. Peterborough Abbey also had soke over 5 manors totalling 2 carucates and 6 bovates. There was also sokeland there of the manor of Tallington, rated at 4 bovates and held by Alvred of Lincoln.
A market was granted by Henry III in 1220 to William Briewer to be held at the manor, and in 1304 King Edward I granted a market and a fair to Joan, widow of John Wak, confirmed with the addition of her son and heir Thomas Wak by Edward II in 1308.