Eyam was held by Karski in 1066 and by the king in 1086, and was assessed at 2 carucates. The earliest historical mention of a church in Eyam is found in the 1291 Taxatio, which valued the rectory of Eyam at £18 6s 8d per annum. In the Domesday Book, Henry I gave the manor of Eyam to William Peverel, though no church was mentioned. The family of Mortegnes held the manor of Eyam under Peverel.